Skip to main content

Annexes

Authors
Affiliations
Océane Blomme

Université de Lille, LEM-CNRS (UMR 9221)

Carl Grekou

IFE-CEPII

Thomas Grjebine

IFE-CEPII

Jérôme Héricourt

Université Paris-Saclay, Université d’Évry Paris-Saclay, CEPS, and IFE-CEPII

Published on

November 18, 2026

Updated on

November 18, 2026

Keywords
Pension reforms, retirement age, funded pensions, fiscal policy, labour supply, local projections
JEL codes
E62, H55, J26, H30, C33

1 Data appendix

Table 1. Data sources
Variables Sources
GDP & productive capacity
GDP GMD
Potential GDP WEO
Labour market outcomes
Older worker labour force participation rate (55-64) OECD
Total labour force participation rate CPDS
Unemployment rate GMD
Consumption & savings
Consumption GMD
Gross domestic savings WDI
Gross savings WDI
Investment
Investment GMD
Fixed investment GMD
Government debt & fiscal space
Public pension expenditure OECD (SOCX)
Central government expenditure GMD
General government expenditure GMD
Central government debt IMF (GDD)
General government debt IMF (GDD)
External sector
Exports GMD
Imports GMD
Trade balance GMD
Current account balance GMD
Productivity
Total factor productivity PWT
GDP per worker (constant USD) GMD & CPDS
Control variables
Old age dependency ratio WDI
Crisis dummy GMD

GMD: Global Macro Database (Müller, Xu, Lehbib, & Chen, 2025)
WEO: World Economic Outlook (IMF)
CPDS: Comparative Political Data Set (Armingeon, Engler, Leemann, & Weisstanner, 2025)
WDI: World Development Indicators (World Bank)
SOCX: Social Expenditure Database (OECD)
GDD: Global Debt Database (IMF)
PWT: Penn World Table (version 10.01) (Feenstra, Inklaar, & Timmer, 2015)

2 Additional results

Figure 1. Robustness check: Placebo tests
(a) GDP (constant USD)
(b) Potential GDP (constant USD)
(c) Consumption (constant USD)
(d) Consumption (%GDP)
(e) Older worker LFPR (55-64)
(f) Labour force participation rate
(g) Gross domestic savings (constant USD)
(h) Gross domestic savings (%GDP)
(i) Investment (constant USD)
(j) Investment (%GDP)
(k) Fixed investment (constant USD)
(l) Fixed investment (%GDP)

Notes: The figure reports the empirical distributions of impulse responses obtained by randomly permuting reforms across country-year observations and re-estimating the local projections (1000 replications). Each distribution corresponds to one projection horizon. Blue densities refer to responses associated with the Age reforms and red densities to responses associated with the Capitalisation reforms. The placebo distributions provide an empirical benchmark for assessing whether random reform timing generates systematic dynamic responses. LFPR denotes labour force participation rate.

Figure 2. Robustness check: Controlling for fiscal consolidations
(a) GDP (constant USD)
(b) Potential GDP (constant USD)
(c) Consumption (constant USD)
(d) Consumption (%GDP)
(e) Older worker LFPR (55-64)
(f) Labour force participation rate
(g) Gross domestic savings (constant USD)
(h) Gross domestic savings (%GDP)
(i) Investment (constant USD)
(j) Investment (%GDP)
(k) Fixed investment (constant USD)
(l) Fixed investment (%GDP)

Notes: The figures report our baseline estimates alongside specifications that additionally control for fiscal consolidation. The baseline specification is extended to include, contemporaneously and with up to three lags, alternative measures of fiscal consolidation: the overall size of the consolidation (Size), spending cuts (Spending), and tax increases (Tax). LFPR denotes labour force participation rate. Inferences based on bootstrapped standard errors (1000 replications). Shaded areas (thin lines) denote the 68% (95%) pointwise confidence intervals.

Figure 3. Robustness check: Controlling for spillovers and external pressure
(a) GDP (constant USD)
(b) Potential GDP (constant USD)
(c) Consumption (constant USD)
(d) Consumption (%GDP)
(e) Older worker LFPR (55-64)
(f) Labour force participation rate
(g) Gross domestic savings (constant USD)
(h) Gross domestic savings (%GDP)
(i) Investment (constant USD)
(j) Investment (%GDP)
(k) Fixed investment (constant USD)
(l) Fixed investment (%GDP)

Notes: The figures report our baseline estimates alongside specifications that additionally control for spillovers and external pressure. The baseline specification is extended to include, contemporaneously and with up to three lags, the leave-one-out means of our age and funded-pension reform measures, as well as the leave-one-out mean of an indicator variable for reform-voting years. LFPR denotes labour force participation rate. Inferences based on bootstrapped standard errors (1000 replications). Shaded areas (thin lines) denote the 68% (95%) pointwise confidence intervals.

Figure 4. Robustness check: Controlling for uncertainty
(a) GDP (constant USD)
(b) Potential GDP (constant USD)
(c) Consumption (constant USD)
(d) Consumption (%GDP)
(e) Older worker LFPR (55-64)
(f) Labour force participation rate
(g) Gross domestic savings (constant USD)
(h) Gross domestic savings (%GDP)
(i) Investment (constant USD)
(j) Investment (%GDP)
(k) Fixed investment (constant USD)
(l) Fixed investment (%GDP)

Notes: The figures report our baseline estimates alongside specifications that additionally control for uncertainty relying on Google Trends data (2004-2025). The baseline specification is extended to include, contemporaneously and with up to three lags, the domestic Google Trends data (domestic uncertainty) as well as the leave-one-out mean of Google Trends data (foreign uncertainty). LFPR denotes labour force participation rate. Inferences based on bootstrapped standard errors (1000 replications). Shaded areas (thin lines) denote the 68% (95%) pointwise confidence intervals.

Bibliography

Armingeon, K., Engler, S., Leemann, L., & Weisstanner, D. (2025). Comparative political data set 1960-2023. Zurich/Lueneburg/Lucerne: University of Zurich, Leuphana University Lueneburg, and University of Lucerne.
Feenstra, R. C., Inklaar, R., & Timmer, M. P. (2015). The next generation of the penn world table. American Economic Review, 105(10), 3150–3182.
Müller, K., Xu, C., Lehbib, M., & Chen, Z. (2025). The global macro database: A new international macroeconomic dataset (Working Paper No. 33714). National Bureau of Economic Research. https://doi.org/10.3386/w33714

Reuse

Citation

BibTeX citation:
@article{blomme2026,
  author = {Blomme, Océane and Grekou, Carl and Grjebine, Thomas and
    Héricourt, Jérôme},
  title = {Annexes},
  journal = {Institut français d’économie working paper},
  number = {2026-14},
  date = {2026-11-18},
  url = {https://www.ofce.fr/wp/2026/14/},
  langid = {en}
}
For attribution, please cite this work as:
Blomme, O., Grekou, C., Grjebine, T., & Héricourt, J. (2026). Annexes. Institut Français d’économie Working Paper, (2026-14). Retrieved from https://www.ofce.fr/wp/2026/14/